A Slice of Greatness

Cheeseburgers you'll flip for!

May 17 2022

With the days getting longer and the weeks getting warmer, it’s time to fire up that grill and make some juicy burgers.  Whether your palate craves the simple and traditional cheeseburger or you are in the mood for something more exotic, Shullsburg Creamery’s burger slices have you covered.  In fact, their unique circular shape happens to provide the perfect coverage for your burger, meaning you’ll experience melted cheesy goodness in every burger bite.  We’re sure you’ll flip over these burger creations!

 

An American Classic – The All-American Cheeseburger

According to legend, a 16-year old boy named Lionel Sternberger first had the idea to put cheese on a hamburger back in 1924 while working in his father’s California-based sandwich shop.  The idea took off and became an American staple!  Luckily, it doesn’t have to be Memorial Day or 4th of July to enjoy this patriotic classic.  Grab some Shullsburg Creamery Mild Cheddar Slices, ketchup, mustard, mayo, lettuce, onion and tomato and start stacking between a sesame-seed bun! 

 

A Tangy Treat – BBQ Avocado Ranch Cheeseburger

We love the way these ingredients play together to infuse the burger with flavor.  For this recipe, mix 3/4th of a ranch packet and a ¼ cup of BBQ sauce into the ground beef to make your patties.  After grilling, immediately top with Shullsburg Creamery Colby Jack Slices.  Then take the remaining 1/4th of the ranch packet and mix with mashed avocado to pile on top!  Try this on a brioche or pretzel bun!

 

On the Border – Southwest Black Bean Turkey Burger

Warning—spiciness ahead!  Combine ground turkey with black beans and a pinch of cumin, cayenne and chili powder to make your patties.  Once grilled, top with Shullsburg Creamery Pepper Jack Slices and a heaping spoon of corn salsa.  Ditch the bun and garnish with tortilla strips!

STAY UP TO DATE

Stay up to date with all things Shullsburg Creamery by subscribing to our newsletter!

* indicates required

By entering your information, you agree to receive marketing communications from Shullsburg Creamery.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING

I purchased three kinds of your cheeses and I fell in love. They're just right - Blueberry , Cranberry and my new favorite, Cheddar with Hot Peppers. They have the right balance of pop. So glad I tried your product! I will be hoping you stay at my store!

-Mary, a Satisfied Customer

Blog

January 26 2026

New Year, New Happenings

While our online store continues to offer a great selection of your favorite Shullsburg Creamery cheeses, for locals or those visiting the town of Shullsburg, a stop at the brick & mortar location is a must-do to see additional goodies not featured online!  The Cheese Store is stocked with new and exciting eats, décor, wearables and much more!
November 20 2025

Bring Shullsburg Creamery to Thanksgiving

When you gather ‘round the table this year with family and friends, make sure you share the goodness by bringing Shullsburg Creamery along for every part of your celebration!
October 27 2025

Meet Rosey, the 2025 Cheesefest Carving

It was one beautiful day at this year's Cheesefest, taking place in historic downtown Water Street earlier this month.  And one of the event's favorite attractions is always the sculpted Cheddar cow.  Shullsburg Creamery proudly donates a 40-pound block of Cheddar each year to sculptor Vicki Janisch, who then does her magic.  We caught up with Vicki to understand the inspiration behind this year's cow!
Wedges of cheese

Shop Online

Shop Online For Shullsburg Creamery Quality Products