Old Fashioned Southern Mac N Cheese

Wisconsin Cheese Meets Classic Southern Cooking

This recipe was submitted by our National Sales Manager, Sonya Leitner, who recently "spiced up" one of her mom's classic recipes using Shullsburg Creamery cheese.
 
Ingredients:
  • 1 ½ bags Noodles (broad no yolk noodles, or any style of noodle you like)
  • 1 Stick Salted Butter
  • 1 can Cheddar Cheese Soup
  • 1 to 1 ½ cups Regular All Purpose Flour
  • 8oz Prairie Farms Whole Milk
  • 2 cups Shullsburg Creamery Sharp Cheddar, shredded
  • 2 cups Shullsburg Creamery Three Pepper Cheddar, shredded
  • Optional - Hot Sauce (add a dash to the mix or use as a topping when eating)
Instructions:
  • Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
  • Cook noodles according to package- once cooked and drained, put back in pot and add ½ stick of butter and mix.
  • In a separate bowl, melt and mix remaining ½ stick of butter  with 8oz of milk, can of soup and 1 cup of flour.
  • Mix in 1 cup of shredded Sharp Cheddar and 1 cup of shredded Three Pepper Cheddar.
  • Add mixture to pot of noodles and mix well.  You may need to add a bit more flour if you prefer a thicker sauce.  You may need to add a bit more milk if you prefer a creamier sauce.  Optional: add hot sauce. Check for consistency before baking.
  • Spray pan and put mixture into pan.  Cover with foil and bake for about 40-50 minutes, until dish appears bubbly.
  • Once cooked, add the remaining shredded cheese on top and put back in oven, uncovered, to melt the rest of the cheese (approximately 5 minutes.)
  • Optional: top with hot sauce.

 

STAY UP TO DATE

Stay up to date with all things Shullsburg Creamery by subscribing to our newsletter!

* indicates required

By entering your information, you agree to receive marketing communications from Shullsburg Creamery.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING

I purchased three kinds of your cheeses and I fell in love. They're just right - Blueberry , Cranberry and my new favorite, Cheddar with Hot Peppers. They have the right balance of pop. So glad I tried your product! I will be hoping you stay at my store!

-Mary, a Satisfied Customer

Blog

January 26 2026

New Year, New Happenings

While our online store continues to offer a great selection of your favorite Shullsburg Creamery cheeses, for locals or those visiting the town of Shullsburg, a stop at the brick & mortar location is a must-do to see additional goodies not featured online!  The Cheese Store is stocked with new and exciting eats, décor, wearables and much more!
November 20 2025

Bring Shullsburg Creamery to Thanksgiving

When you gather ‘round the table this year with family and friends, make sure you share the goodness by bringing Shullsburg Creamery along for every part of your celebration!
October 27 2025

Meet Rosey, the 2025 Cheesefest Carving

It was one beautiful day at this year's Cheesefest, taking place in historic downtown Water Street earlier this month.  And one of the event's favorite attractions is always the sculpted Cheddar cow.  Shullsburg Creamery proudly donates a 40-pound block of Cheddar each year to sculptor Vicki Janisch, who then does her magic.  We caught up with Vicki to understand the inspiration behind this year's cow!
Wedges of cheese

Shop Online

Shop Online For Shullsburg Creamery Quality Products